I belong to a wonderful book club made up of twelve smart and savvy people who love to read. We all adore books, and we’re very social, but we’re also just a little bit geeky (and I mean that in the nicest possible way). I knew we all had embraced the digital world, but I was still rather amazed when it dawned on me that between us we were reading on every major device available in Canada. We have an iPad, a Sony Reader, a Kindle, a Kobo and a few iPhones and Blackberrys.

So I asked everyone to bring their favourite e-reader to our last meeting for a little show and tell. I also asked folks to champion their preferred device. Here’s what they had to say:
Sandra received a Kobo for Mother’s Day…
I like the Kobo e-reader because of its price point. At $149, it’s a much easier decision to make to take the plunge to an e-reader. It isn’t too “precious” - I’d be worried about running around with an iPad or something more expensive or fragile. And the e-book purchases are through Indigo, a Canadian company. The stylish aqua leather case isn’t too bad either! -Sandra
Lisa is the proud new owner of an iPad…
I had never considered an e-reader until my husband purchased an iPad. I really did not expect to like it as much as I do. It’s small enough to hold and read in bed, more compact than my laptop and the colour and images are gorgeous. I think I prefer to read printed books but I plan to load up some ebooks to our iPad for an upcoming family vacation. If there’s enough memory and a camera in the next generation iPad, it will probably become my computer. The keyboard is not great so I would need an auxiliary keyboard and obviously still need a phone (I love my Blackberry for email and phone). So the iPad and Blackberry are the perfect combination for me. I can see the appeal of dedicated e-readers, but given the prices I can’t see myself buying one. -Lisa

Elle is the proud owner of a Kindle…
I got my Kindle six months ago, for Christmas, and I can say honestly it has been the best Christmas present ever. When I travel, my husband has always joked about needing an extra suitcase to pack my books. Now I can just load up the Kindle and I only need to take one. While I know the device isn’t perfect (no ability to lock documents, not a terribly efficient “filing” system and a completely inexplicable “page numbering” system) many of these problems are the result of being a first generation product. The Kindle does do other things very well: you can bookmark documents, “highlight” passages and take notes - all valuable features when you spend time reviewing books. Also, as a person who is notorious for flipping to the end to find out how a book ends (yes, I cheat) it forces you to read in the moment. Lastly, I love that the screen is NOT backlit - it really does replicate the book-reading experience remarkably well. The Kindle will never replace physical books. I love the shape and feel and smell of real books, and there is something to be said for the ability to flip back easily to a prior page to remind yourself of something you read previously, but for those books you may never read again, or for space saving, you can’t lose with the Kindle.
I have a Sony Reader. While I’m lusting after the iPad, it won’t replace my Sony Reader for books. No backlighting and no wireless are features, not drawbacks for me. I like to read for hours at a time, and e-ink is easy on the eyes. Plus, I have a little case of ADD, and not being able to check Twitter for a few hours is a good thing for me.

Though most of us are e-reading at least some of the time, we still have a couple if devotees of the printed book. Alice is a Librarian and she’s not buying a smart phone or an e-reader anytime soon…
I read blogs and news online, but when it comes to novels, I want to curl up with a book. Partly because they are easier on the eyes, partly simply the tactile pleasure and book design, a “device” is just not the same as a book. I am, frankly, not even tempted. (Plus, spilling tea on a book is not nearly as disastrous!) -Alice