Last week in our editorial meeting my colleagues and I were discussing John Boyne’s forthcoming novel, Mutiny on the Bounty (early 2009). As is bound to happen when talking about a historical event that has been documented, recreated, and interpreted by Hollywood, we fell into the debate of which film was best. Directors Lewis Milestone and Carol Reed’s 1962 film, starring the late actors Richard Harris and Marlon Brando, was the outright winner amongst our group, but this caused me to wonder (onto the keys of my computer): How does Brando’s portrayal of lead mutineer Fletcher Christian and his conquest compare to the one, and the story, of John Boyne? If we put Brando and Boyne on parallel planks and made them walk, who would sink to the bottom of the Pacific and who would float to the surface?
If we’re putting a wager on it, my money’s on Boyne to float. You may know him as the author of 2006’s young adult sensation, The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, or from one of his four other published novels.
Everyone knows the story of the Bounty. In case you don’t, the Coles notes version is thus: Captained by the now-infamous William Bligh, boat sets sail for Tahiti (or Otaheite, as Boyne’s Bligh prefers). Crew remains happy on long voyage. Bounty arrives at Tahiti. Crew enjoys island life. Bounty departs for return voyage. Mutiny, led by Master’s Mate Fletcher Christian, occurs and Captain and seventeen others are shoved of in a puny launch to return to England, or die trying. Bounty returns to Tahiti and crew abandons their King’s mission to continue enjoying island life.
You may ask, “If I know the story of the Bounty, why should I bother reading this novel? ” Please indulge me. Allow me to answer that, and to tell you why my money is on John Boyne.
Boyne’s version of the Bounty’s journey is told from the perspective of the person whose ears are privy to the most detailed information aboard and the one closest to Captain Bligh himself. In the same way he did with Bruno in The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, John Boyne puts the reader in the King’s-issued uniform of “Turnip” and takes you on a journey unlike any of the Bounty films. John Jacob Turnstile, a young orphan plucked from his life as a petty thief in the streets of Portsmouth, tells his story with more tension, excitement, and honesty than you could hope for. Boyne’s protagonist pulls you into berth his outside the Captain’s suite to rub his back as he suffers seasickness and makes you feel parched and hungry during times of strict rationing. You will explore Tahiti in a whole new way (and for those who have never visited, myself included, you will encounter for the first time). You will see ship-life in a fresh light. You will see a side of one of history’s most publicly defeated loyalists that you never have, and that you possibly never expected to. You will meet a young man whose naivety will sometimes make you roll your eyes and cause you to chuckle, and whose life story, whose belief in those around him will by turns exasperate you and break your heart (If you’re anything like me, he might make you cry).
With is careful eye and writing hand, John Boyne constructs a full crew, from quartermaster to cook. History has given us a one-dimensional sense of the achievements (a term used more loosely for some than others, I’d say) of Captain Bligh, Fletcher Christian, John Fryer, and their warrant officers, able seamen, and petty officers aboard the Bounty, but here they come alive in the most engaging way. In this novel these men are not just sailors, but friends, lovers, and free thinkers. The kind of men whose company you want to stay in for all of its pages.
On the recommendation of my colleagues I rented the 1962 Mutiny on the Bounty film. Sure, it has the credentials of its Academy Award and Golden Globe nominations and various award wins behind it, but it lacks the pure heart and passion this novel carries from the first word to the last. I can’t wait this novel to be published so I can enjoy it again in its finished form. It’s the kind of book you can, and will, get lost in. The kind of book where the pages turn themselves. The kind of book you will want to take everywhere with you go. Even on holiday. Especially to Tahiti.
(If you haven’t read John Boyne’s The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, do so. Even if you’re an adult. Actually, especially if you are an adult.)